Best Restaurants Open for Newyears Eve this year in Show Low – 2024

Love this place and in my opinion these burgers are the best you can get anywhere! Had the Butter Burger Deluxe double (so yummy, soft buttered and grilled bun, juicy meat, melted cheese, all the fixings) with cheese curds (super delicious) that came with cheese sauce that is warm, also had the pretzel bites with warm cheese sauce ( definitely ordering these again) their Root Beer is top-notch, husband ordered their strawberry salad with vinaigrette and he liked it but said the chicken was a little salty, he also got their birthday blueberry frozen custard with a cake pop on top. He loved it, I did not at all but I've had great custard here and blueberry is just not for me. Highly recommend especially at $35 out the door!

My niece/nieces and their grandpa like to dine here a lot. I come here every so often only as the driver or to meet up with them. They tend to order the butterbuger and cod dinner/cod sandwich. I like the cod sometimes (to get my omega-3 fatty acids) and the grilled chicken sandwich. Also, their ice cream (chocolate cone) is always, always yummy (not sure if it was custard)!!!!!Yesterday, I brought my dad there after his doctor's appointment. He had the cod dinner with onion rings. The one thing we always noticed is that the burgers tasted under-seasoned (bland). And, the cod as well. Maybe they are just concerned about the customer's who might have high blood pressure or something...who knows? So, we always grab some of the salt and pepper packets that are available by the soda fountain. Or, maybe the cooks are just too young and inexperiened. The 2 guys yesterday were working hard. The gals seemed to be distracted and were talking amongst themselves. One of the workers was a tall/loud gal. I'm sure she is sweet and sincere, but she really needs to turn the volumn of her speaking voice down several notches. :-D Waited in the order line 2-3 times to get more food, etc. I finally had to ask one of the gals if she was ready to take my order. She seemed surprised that someone would ask her such a question. I think the problem with many restaurants nowadays, is that they have a tendancy to hire workers who are just too young and under-trained. But, I guess that is just how it is and the adults really don't want to work at a chain restaurant. Oh, worth mentioning is the fact that the food reminded us of the food we had in Pennsylvania (plain/tasteless) when we lived there for many years. Thank goodness for salt and pepper!! 5 stars for the 2 guys and the atmosphere of the place. *****

Was pretty surprised at how nice this Culver's is. This is a chain fast food restaurant that serves butter burgers and fish. At least that stood out to me. The restaurant is clean and the choice of drinks are nice. There's quite a big selection of ice cream as well. The wait time wasn't an issue when I went.

Our papa loves to eat breakfast here after his doctor's appointment. He orders their pancakes and eggs. The owner, Monica, always greets him with a hug and smile. I like the hamburger (medium) with gravy and over medium eggs. Wish they had brown gravy, though. Had the coconut pie once. It was yummy!

Great little place, friendly staff and fantastic service. Had the Corned Beef Hash and a taste of my friend’s Biscuits and Gravy, all was great and tasty. The Gravy was delicious! Home cooking, stop by and try it out!

This place is located where Sweetheart used to be. Monica is an amazing person. Congrats on your own place ! This was my first of many visits to come to this place. I knew when I found out it was you that I would have no disappointment. The food, service, and everything were amazing even with how packed the place was. I look forward to my next visit. It was worth driving an hour and half for lunch at this place.went for lunch today with a friend and business friend as well. Qw both enjoyed yet another great meal

I couldn't give this business a higher rating. We stopped in because we needed a place to eat and relax close to the EV chargers at the county building. The food was incredible and affordable. The environment was super modern and family oriented, clean, and accommodating. A great place to being friends for food and drinks and the whole family. There is amazing outdoor dining all year round with heaters outside and fire pits. There was lights at night which were gorgeous and during the day families enjoyed the cornhole and people brought their dogs. The restaurant was so accommodating to the dogs that they brought them water bowls and the area is so large that you get a private dining experience without feeling like people are too close to you. The staff was very attentive. Every staff member I saw was doing something or assisting a customer. You get a family restaurant type feel that is not lax in their customer service by any means. Who ever runs this place runs a tight ship. The outdoor bar had a ton of options to choose from. It was so good we had to come back through on our way back home and it will not be our favorite restaurant away from home.

So happy we found this place. We sat outside and ordered drinks and food with the bartender. The drinks were great and the food was yummy as well. We shared the french dip and they split it for us. The sandwich was huge! The food did take a long time to come out but we weren't in a rush. We were there for a late lunch on Sunday and they had some live music outside. Very relaxing atmosphere during the day.

The House was recommended by a friend plus was at the top of the list at our hotel. It was amazing. The best burger on a bed of greens (Barn Burger). My husband's double (Barn Burger) burger was enormous. Too big for even him. The side salad was amazing. And the housemade chips were delicious. My daughter loved the street tacos, rice, and beans. We tried to come back the next night but by the time we arrived back in Show Low around 6:15 pm on a Saturday night it was packed with nowhere to park so we had to find a different restaurant. We did, but it didn't even compare. Thank you for providing amazing food in a relaxed atmosphere.

My friend and I ordered take out breakfast to share with a group. The service, atmosphere and the food is so delicious! The portions are large so 1 meal fed two. We had the Three Amigo Tacos, Hillbilly Hash, Florentine Eggs Benedict, donuts and a large loaf of sourdough bread. We all recommend Bertie’s if you haven’t tried it!

This restaurant is a perfect example of why you should always eat at a small locally owned place while you're traveling. It was definitely everything that we could have asked for. I find that 90% of the time it is far superior to a chain restaurant. The friend that I was visiting in Show Low had never been there either. She ordered something Ala carte that she loved. I got the hillbilly hash and couldn't have been happier. The portion was generous at a fair price and the server was polite and helpful. I'm not sure when I'll be back in Show Low, but, I promise I'll get some hillbilly hash when I do.

Small town charm and atmosphere in one place. We didn't get to try their homemade donuts and pastries because there is always a line. So, they must be as good as they look and smell. The food is good. Check out their bar stools, too.

We’ve been here a handful of times when we needed a cheeseburger and every time it’s been fantastic food!! I always get the mushroom burger and there’s a good amount of mushrooms on it! We will definitely be back next season!!

I had the Chili Burger with no cheese. The burger patty was decently sized and moist. The condiments were fresh and overall a great burger. The one star off was the chili was dry. I was expecting to have a sopping wet Texas chili style, but I guess they would have said Texas style. The proprietors were great and accommodating. I definitely will return to try the other burgers. The only star off was for the chili

My Hole In One burger was very good. Fresh, juicy and loaded with toppings. The bun was fresh too. There are few amenities here, but the people were friendly.

The girls taking your order are not friendly or very helpful. They are more interested in the other workers then helping the customer with their order and making sure the customer is happy, there are other places to spend your hard earned money with better service.

Banditos is great for taqueria food. They were fast with the takeout. The prices are fantastic. The guacamole was excellent. Salsas were fresh and delicious. Fresh warm chips. I'd give it 5 stars, but the taste I wanted from the taco and enchilada was just not there. The sauce seemed canned. It was ok though. The rice is kind of bland, but the beans were really good. We have gone there a couple of times now. I'd recommend it for a quick meal on a budget.

I really like the food here. I think its one of the best kept secrets on the mountain. It's as close to authentic New Mexico that I have found here. Girl at the counter is always friendly. I paid $30 for birria tacos for pick up at another Mexican restaurant, these were better. I like the birria tacos a little crispier but still really good. Thanks!

Wow, what an excellent lunch and dinner location in Show Low with tons of ample parking. The avocado toast really put several decent Phoenix eateries to shame with fresh sliced avocado. A bit messy to eat but so tasty. Their brunch options looked enticing but we would love an early breakfast opening (please.)

As a vegan, it can sometimes be challenging to find a restaurant that offers both delicious and healthy options. We were happy to find PersNIKKIty's, which exceeded our expectations! The staff was incredibly informative and helpful, answering all my questions.The restaurant itself was clean and inviting, and the food was absolutely delicious. We left feeling perfectly satisfied. I highly recommend PersNIKKIty's to anyone looking for a great dining experience! Ordered: Veggie Burger with shoestring fries (no parm), Falafel pita & salad w/raspberry vinaigrette.

Holy moly, my husband and I both got the avocado bacon burrito and can I just say it was hands down the best breakfast burrito I’ve ever had. Who knew tater tots in a burrito would be so good? We definitely plan on making this a stop every time we come to Show Low.

Service was especially good, our waiter was quite efficient. Lunch menu food options are large portions. Lighting in booth we were seated in left a lot to be desired.

The food was delicious as always! 6 staff was absolutely wonderful, my co-workers and I got off work late for an out of town job, and they stayed open for us. I wish I remembered our servers name because I'd 100% recommend a raise for him. He was on top of his game, as was other staff! 100% will return!

Good food with lunch specials. Enchiladas and tacos were large and meaty. Tried something different had the no cholesterol point beans mixed with don't of their homemade salsa it was a good healthy choice. Plenty of chips salsa during the shirt wait for our food. Servers were very attentive. Beautiful decorated booths with plenty of Mexican cultural art on display. Highly recommend.

A typical Mexican restaurant vibe with a colorful seating area and custom booth carvings. On the outside this place looks average and unfortunately the service matched... was just ok. The food was good but some items had little to no flavor; as Mexican dishes are expected to have some spice or unique to the establishment. They have an overwhelming menu and when we ordered different dishes we found the same bland sauce on multiple dishes. Understandable when maintaining costs, just a little disappointing to see. The specialty drink concoctions we tried were spectacular on the pictures but fell VERY short when actually presented. We have given this place 4 visits in the past year and each time waited a long time to be seated. No one seems to help other staff in order to provide a better experience for the customers. For example, the host would be busy taking a phone order and have 2 or three people waiting to be seated (including us). 2 waitresses walked by pointing to the people waiting and all the host could simply do was acknowledge and carry on with the call. No waitresses took it upon themselves to help seat guests. However they did check every minute or so by stopping to look at the front door and see if anyone had been seated. Unfortunately, this unenthusiastic service carried through each of our visits. Note: we ate in the barside once. No one served us until we went to the front desk and the cocktails were overly sweet and had no balance. It's an ok spot for the area but it could be better if they put a little more effort into their dishes and service.

I wouldn’t call this restaurant “typical” like another reviewer. Sounds like they’ve never had Midwest Mexican food and are spoiled by the delicious variety we have in Arizona. This place is worth the stop. We chose this over having drive through in a bag or another cheeseburger from an “American food restaurant “ on our way back to Tucson. The menu is extensive. Even the kids menu has huge variety for little picky eaters. Right away we had a hard time ordering just one thing. The plates are huge so sharing is great but do it family style, fill up the table, and try all the things! Leftovers are always great. We ended up choosing Barría tacos and a carnitas burrito. The atmosphere was pleasant because it was cozy inside. I loved the decor from murals to a veranda style table that made you feel like you were at family gatherings on the patio. I watched the staff and they all seemed polished and happy. Bathroom was clean and well stocked. They were always busy sweeping or clearing up a table. When the food came out, quickly, we devoured our birria tacos and carnitas burritos, sharing bites across the table and enjoying the futbol game ⚽️ We go up north a lot and will take the time to stop in and try something new ⛺️☀️

Birria here is INCREDIBLE. Flavors were absolutely on point, even the consumme was packed with good flavors. The chile crisp was also very good, little milder flavors, definitely good pick if spicy isnt your go-to. Can never go wrong with a good cream cheese sauce (Level it up with some hatch chile and you're set). Portion for price is exactly where I am happy with it. But the main key here is service. Right after my drink order was taken, two more people walking by asked if I already had drinks ordered, brought chips and salsa, and then drinks were right there shortly after. At every step of the way, the service was attentive. Refill at half a glass attentive. From walking in, to leaving was 43 minutes, but it was so comfortable and I was so caught up in my food I was sure I had been there all night. Even the free salsa had great flavors, some chunks in there from being blended so can tell its not bought in.

Visiting ShowLow for honeys 32nd bday and seen amazing reviews of this place. We ordered a large meat lover , medium pepperoni and garlic bread… everything was DELICIOUS! would definitely recommend and order again! Thank you

Have been here a many times no issues. Always ask for a veggie pizza or a cheese pizza that is on its own pan, no meat. I am allergic to most meat. Never had an issue in the past. Cashier lady was so rude to tell me they don't do requests for the buffet. Could have been nice and say sorry, can't do that. Proceeded to tell me cheese never touches meat pizza 3 times. Yet on the buffet was a pepperoni and a cheese, cooked together. Have been going here for years, no one has ever had an issue making a full veggie pizza or just a plain full cheese, then the way she said it, so rude.

Best A.Y.C.E. Salad bar in this area. About $11.50 per adult plate. Last year, it was $8.99/plate that's about a 18% increase in pricing. (Darn Inflation ) I did learn on this visit that they do offer a discount for Military, Police, Fire/EMT. Kids salad bar discount is for 6 and under. Amazing selection of salad toppings . I hope they add: Avacado, Red Bell Peppers, & Dried Cranberries. Also, it would be awesome if their produce was sourced locally from farmers (when in season).

I was so looking forward to a really good salad and burger for dinner. I ordered a burger with cheese and bacon with green leaf lettuce wrap. It arrived with just 1 /2 leaf on the bottom and 1/2 leaf on the top. Not nearly enough to pick it up like a sandwich. I would have ordered a side salad but all they had was iceberg lettuce which I cannot digest. The burger was good. I also ordered the broccoli cheddar soup for my side and I didn't get it until I asked about it when my burger arrived. It was very thin and I never saw any broccoli in it. It wouldn't fill me up so I skipped the calories. I should have ordered the green beans - they looked green and al dente. My dinner didn't fill me up so I went back to the hotel and got more food to finish my meal. My husband loved his gravy smothered chicken and fried mushrooms. My daughter really liked her chicken sandwich and French fries. My son in law really liked his steak and mashed potatoes with gravy but it was even too rare for him. At least they were all full. If you are looking for good fried foods I think this is the place. It seemed everyone around us ordered onion rings, fried appetizers, and steaks.

I stopped in here with my Mom after a day of traveling. I had the prime rib and she had a steak. Everything was perfectly cooked and the service was outstanding. If you are in showlow i highly recomend cattleman's, you will not be disappointed.

Been trying to check Cattleman's out for some time now, but our schedule didn't permit. Last time in Showlow, AZ, made it a point to stop in and we weren't disappointed. The service and food was terrific. I have to say, the Prime Rib was one of the best pieces of meat I've had in a long time. Very flavorful and tender. And the plate wasn't loaded down with a bunch of nonsense you get at some steak houses. Just a salad, baked potato, and the steak (of course, the Horse Radish as well). Very good. Will make it a point to stop in the next time in the area.

Pitalian is by far my favorite restaurant. Pizza is exquisite and made in actual pizza oven. Puff bread is not enough words to describe it, but to sum it up. Yummy, very yummy super. Yummy, love it so much yummy. You should definitely come here cause it is very yummy.Lots of stuff is yummy. If you're a fan of italian food come here soup is very yummy. This is the best place I've ever been to. Puff bread is very yummy. PLEASE COME TRY. Best place ever. So good we took it home.- written by my 11 year old son.

Great tasting pizza with many options to build your own. There was a big lunch crowd but all the workers were happy to serve. The guy assembling my pizza said it only takes 2 minutes for the pizza to cook, that's amazingly fast!

Amazing pizza for a great price! Me and my family of 4 were able to chow down on two pizzas and it was plenty! The staff is great and very attentive, I definitely recommend this spot if looking for a quick yet tasty pizza!