Best Restaurants Open for Newyears Eve this year in Plum – 2024

I wish I had taken pictures of our food, but I did not! The deep dish pizza was out of this world! It did not disappoint. And the cupcakes…just incredible! This is such a charming spot, the owners were so kind and friendly, and you could tell their passion is pizza! I highly recommend!!

As Meredith Palmer once said “The Man is a Genius” this pizza is legit. So thankful for an amazing deep dish in the area.

Why is this place not more popular! Ok, so I was craving deep dish pizza, and this place popped up 10 min from UPMC East. Most of the reviews are good, but when I arrived, the place was dead.. no customers. Employees were cool and presented me with my pizza and cupcake. Told me have a good evening, and I was out. Pizza looked good, but I was worried as like I said no other customers in the shop. Got home, and WOW pizza was great. I mean, I was truly surprised. Buttery crust, nice pepperoni, and sausage. Whoever is making the pies at this joint....CHEF KISS!! Will be back, and you should go to! Pay em a visit, get a pie, and do a Die Hard! Deep dish! Edit!!! And I'm back again, who made these cupcakes!!!! And where do I get more? This is insane. This place needs more foot traffic. And I need more Vanilla Cookie Butter cupcakes!!!

Enjoyed a dinner out with the girls. It had been a long time since I was there so I suggested it. We weren't disappointed. The eggplant Parmesan was delicious and my friend had the stuffed sole which she loved. Our service was excellent. The worst thing was trying to decide which dessert to try. They all looked amazing! The orange creamcicle cake was excellent. I highly recommend checking it out.

Our waitress was excellent and the food was delicious. The chicken parm was wonderful and a large serving and the chicken romano! We arrived just as they opened. Great dinner. The bathroom was super tight.

I have been pleasantly surprised each time I've been here (this is like my 3rd time). The restaurant has been there forever and is never packed, so that has made me hesitate. Boy, I will never hesitate to go here again. The service is always excellent - friendly - while not too much that it's overbearing; and they are knowledgeable on what food they serve. hey Now the food...delicious! Tonight, we had the prime rib and WOW! Great size, flavor, and price. I would prefer deserts that are homemade, but that's hard to find anywhere lately. They have Moio's cake, so at least they're not those desserts that you can get at most other restaurants; but still not homemade. This didn't bother me enough to take a star away, though. And though the restaurant is older and has older stuff in it, it is cute & clean. And I LOVE that they are never packed. Makes it cozy. Update from 07/24: Everything is still great! Love it here.

Got a large Pepperoni, Onion, 1/2 Mushroom & 1/2 Black Olives and 12 Garlic Parmesan wing. Perfect dinner for 3. Great food at a good price and excellent service!

Ordered a large pizza half plain and half with mushrooms. We prepaid so all we had to do was pick it up. We made it home to realize it was an all cheese pizza. We paid extra for the mushrooms. The pizza was average quality. We’re unsure we will be returning for a while.

Have lived in Plum for years and never tried this pizza until today. Was our first time but definitely won’t be our last! White pizza was delicious. Happy to have a good pizza shop so close to home!